Monthly archives: October, 2006

Book of Doom: DMZ #12

This week, we’re branching out into another non-superhero book for the Books of Doom. Between today and Saturday, pick up DMZ #12 at your local comic shop and come back this weekend to share your thoughts and read ours.

While DMZ has been going on for awhile, this issue provides a standalone between arcs and should give a good introduction to the series. Here’s Vertigo’s summary:

Written by Brian Wood; Art and cover by Wood

In this special stand-alone issue, Brian Wood supplies both script and art and gives readers an in-depth look at life, culture and the unique neighborhoods within the DMZ. Think of it as a tourist guide to one of the most dangerous destinations on Earth – Manhattan, New York City: the DMZ.



Doomed to Repeat Them?

It was announced last Friday after a few weeks of speculation that Thunderbolts will be receiving a major makeover early next year courtesy of Warren Ellis and Mike Deodato. Essentially spinning off of the team of Thunderbolts seen on the last page of Civil War #4, the new Thunderbolts will ditch the continuity that has kept current T-Bolts fans pleased as punch in favor of what is being described as a Suicide Squad rip-off. My question to Marvel: don’t you remember what happened last time?

Old New ThunderboltsA few years ago, due to a gradual drop in sales that’s almost inevitable for all comics these days, Thunderbolts was drastically overhauled for the first time. Gone were the Thunderbolts fans had read for 75 issues (who had only recently reunited under the leadership of Baron Zemo) in favor of what was always referred to as a superhero version of Fight Club. The series kept the existing numbering and title, despite never mentioning the word “Thunderbolts” in the actual story. Six issues later, the relaunch was deemed a bonafide flop and the series was promptly cancelled.

Now Marvel seems poised to make the same mistake they made back then by replacing what Thunderbolts fan love about the series with what they think Thunderbolts fans love about the series.

New ThunderboltsTo Marvel, it seems, Thunderbolts is first and foremost a book about supervillains. I distinctly remember those words being used the first time the series was revamped, and it certainly seems to be the case this time around. How could a team that’s led by the Green Goblin and includes Bullseye and Venom be seen as anything other than a team of supervillains? Those characters don’t have a single heroic bone in their body.

But to us fans, Thunderbolts had always been a book about superheroes. Yes, most of them are reformed villains. Yes, many of the characters don’t have the noblest of intentions for performing heroic deeds. But the underlying thread of the book has always been a band of hard-luck heroes trying desperately to do good things despite their own inexperience, insecurities and villainous pasts. Thunderbolts is a book about redemption, and Marvel just doesn’t seem to get that.

(more…)



#1 Thing that made me smile- Spidey being Spidey

Robert Kirkman just gets Spider-Man. Sure, there are a lot of guys that get Spider-Man, but most of them aren’t writing Spider-Man stories. And there are a lot of guys that don’t get him that are writing his stories. So when Spidey does something very Spidey-esque, I can’t help but get giddy like a school girl. And that happens every single time Spider-Man showed up in Robert Kirkman’s Marvel Team-Up. It’s a shame #25 was the final issue, because it means no more great lines like this one.

MTU 25



#2 Thing that made me smile- Nightwing doesn’t suck anymore!

Nightwing 125aNobody liked Bruce Jones’ Nightwing. Literally. Show me someone that says they liked it, and I’ll show you a liar that I will proceed to punch in the face, chest and abdomen until I get tired and Doom DeLuise has to take over.

But y’know what? Marv Wolfman seems to know what the hell he’s doing. Hell, the character even seems to acknowledge that he sucked there for half a year or so. Nightwing/Wolfman pretty much just come out and say what we can all agree with: Nightwing’s at his best when he’s kicking ass like Batman but not being a dick afterwards. Or, to phrase it differently: Nightwing’s at his best when he kicks ass like Batman but is still being Dick afterwards.

Oh, and in your breaking-the-fourth-wall moment of the weak, a mysterious character announces that Nightwing should have died in Infinite Crisis. Then, in your ominous-foreshadowing-by-the-villain moment, the same mysterious villain says he plans to rectify that mistake. And by “mysterious character,” I of course mean one of the new Watchers Monitors, which DC already revealed was going to be following Dick Grayson around. I’m not sure if anyone told Marv Wolfman that we all know that, though.

Oh well. It’s still leaps and bounds ahead of albino twins with opposite superpowers hiring a giant spider guy to eat Jason Todd only to get soundly defeated by some uninteresting chick in Nigtwing’s costume while the actual Nightwing acts like a dick. No capital D.



#3 Thing that made me smile- Crime doesn’t pay–as well as legally tricking rich people to give you their money

Detective 824

Paul Dini is writing the best Batman stories I’ve ever read. Okay, to be fair, I didn’t start reading Batman until OYL, but it’s definitely better than the “Face to Face” arc and much, much better than what Morrison’s doing over on Batman (you don’t know how bad I wanted to do a pun on that title, but they all sounded really juvenile–all right, check the bottom of the post for my stupid jokes).

Where was I? Oh yes, Paul Dini’s Detective Comics. The Riddler’s new role as a legit private dick that’s a sex machine with absolutely no one is sweet. Now Penguin’s started a legitimate nightclub/casino (gambling’s legal in Gotham?), albeit it with non-legit start-up funds. So when Misters Nigma and Cobblepot get a chance to chat amongst themselves, what do they talk about? How much easier it is to legally take loads off cash from people instead of stealing it, of course. Sure took them villainous folk long enough to figure that one out.

Okay, now my bad puns (I’m warning you here):
Buttman- because it’s barely a step up from ASSBAR
Badman- because it’s bad
Crapman- because it’s crap
Defective Comics- too bad Morrison’s writing Batman or else this one actually would have been great



Memo to Marv Wolfman

For awhile now, we’ve been on a sort of Nightwing Watch here at the Legion of Doom. He should have died in Infinite Crisis. Everybody agrees on that now. Instead, Dick moved to New York, acted like a Grade A Asshole and fought some pointlessly retarded villains. Instead of a real conclusion to the story, DC disappeared Bruce Jones and brought in old-time Teen Titans scribe Marv Wolfman. Now, here’s a guy who knows Dick Grayson.

Nightwing #125 came out this week, Marv’s first stab at rehabbing Nightwing, who was fast on his way to becoming an utterly worthless hero. So, what did we get?

First, the best parts: Tops were the mysterious voice telling Dick that he should have died in the Crisis. I have no clue where this is going, but it’ll be interesting to see. Also, Dick’s alter ego, Captain Cockhead, is nowhere to be seen. Hooray.

Now, the bad: Wolfman and artist Dan Jurgens desperately need to realize it’s not 1986 anymore. You sort of have to read the book to get the complete feel of this (and I’m too lazy to scan pages), but this book felt like something I pulled out of the quarter bin. It has the now rarely used thought bubbles – “This is great. I want to enjoy it, but the more I try to think about things other than crime fighting, the more I can’t stop thinking about it.” It has a hokey new villain – Raptor, who’s strikingly familiar to Spider-Man’s Killer Shrike. It has numerous encounters between Dick and two random hot chicks living in his apartment that seem right out of Ferris Bueller’s Day Off.

And, while both Dan Jurgens and Norm Rapmund are decent enough artists on their own, somehow together they turn in one of those standard ’80s type books that almost reminds me of why Rob Liefeld was popular when he first came on the scene to shake things up. Everyone wears ’80s clothes, most notably the aforementioned hot chicks (an orange sports bra and purple bicycle shorts???).

And yet, the main thing to say about Nightwing #125 is that it’s infinitely better than the series’ previous run.



Book of Doom: Criminal #1

Hey everybody, it’s that time of the week again! This week we’re reviewing Criminal #1 by Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips from Marvel’s Icon imprint. I liked the book but I’m not quite sure why. Maybe my fellow Doomers can help me put my finger on it.

Criminal 1Jean Claude Van Doom:
“The shop was sold out. So, based on my fandom for Mr. Brubaker, the incredible reviews it’s gotten, the great art, the cool plotlines, I’m sure it’s terrible. Thank goodness the shop was sold out.”

That sucks. Let’s try the next one.

Doom DeLuise:
“I don’t get it.

I’m sure that after I read the next few issues, everything in Criminal #1 will make perfect sense, but, as of right now, I just don’t get it. Just like the protagonist with the Frank Kafka comic. I’ll hold off judgment until I read the next few issues. This first one, though, leaves me with the impression that I just cannot say anything about it, since it makes such little sense, and we’re given such little amount of story. The art’s pretty, and I have faith in the writer, so, eventually, I’m sure this will be pretty cool, but the first issue leaves me with nothing to say.”

(more…)



#4 Thing that made me smile- That fat nurse in Criminal

Because I’m lazy, I’m making this #4 because then it posts the same day as the group review. Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man or The Irredeemable Antman probably deserves it more, but like I said, I’m lazy. I did four other heartfelt ones and two countdowns last week. Give me a break, will ya? Anyway, I wish this woman was real, so I could see her freak out somewhere. That’d be funny as hell.

Criminal 1 Int



Doomazing Spider-Meme

Doomazing Spider-MemeSo this is the first one of these here thingies I’ve ever participated in. The freakish positioning of J. Jonah Jameson’s right hand just screamed out at me. This one comes from Chris over at 2 Guys Buying Comics. I believe the general rule is the dirtier the funnier, right?



#5 Thing that made me smile- Doctor Strange: The Oath

Doctor Strange 1

Y’know, Dr. Strange is a really cool character. Unlike the DC Universe, there aren’t a gazillion magic-type guys to fight back the forces of all the dark dimensions surrounding our own. It’s pretty much all on Dr. Strange. And he must be really, really good at it, or else we wouldn’t exist. Or he’s just lies about it all, which is cool in another way.

But Dr. Strange hasn’t been really cool for a while. He was in Avengers: Disassembled for about two seconds and stole what little glory there was from the Avengers, who deserved any glory there might have been after what they went through. Not cool. He’s in the Illuminati. Not cool. He was in a stupid Matrix rip-off mini-series which should have been Ultimate Strange but was supposed to replace the 616 origin (but thankfully didn’t) drawn by Jim Doom’s favorite artist. Definitely not cool.

But the Oath is cool. Very cool. But what else do you expect from Brian K. Vaughn, the best writer working in comics today that isn’t really considered a “superstar” (and a better writer than a lot of those that are).